15 thoughts on “Is Amazon.com catching the eBay disease?”

  1. Pingback: AuctionWire
  2. One question : is this deal only about the integration of the catalogue inside amazon.com ?

    Could make as much money if they sale the wharehouse and computer (S3) infrastructure in BtoB. What do you think ?

    On my view the website is on the verge of getting out of Amazon core competencies. API, S3, Unbox, Wharehouse … are now the real keys.

  3. I was the design director on one of the big ten retailer sites when they first hit the net (1999-2000) and we always wondered why others (biggies) were signing up with Amazon in the first place. They have the brand, they need to control their own destiney and don’t need an Amazon skimming off some of the cream. I’m amazed that it’s taken this long for them to bail.
    Bet the next is Target.

  4. I should ammend my comment slightly…
    The big hurdle at the time was not the font or backend of the site, it was distribution. The big retailers were set up to send semis loaded with goods to distribution centers and individual stores, not individual orders to homes/businesses. So, Amazon helped in that respect.

  5. “A retailer looking to acquire customers doesn’t need big marketplaces, because Google Adwords (and other such tools) do a pretty good job of directing buyers their way”

    I think the primary strength here is that eBay has buyer/seller feedback, something that won’t be identifiable if someone is simply directed to a site’s homepage for a sole proprietor(if they aren’t a large & well-known brand, customers are going to be somewhat wary about buying from a site that they know nothing about).

    Disclaimer: I used to work for eBay/PayPal. And while eBay has obvious problems, I do think that the feedback platform still helps folks a lot.

  6. Yes, I think the eBay feedback does help (although note you have to evaluate eBay feedback with a cynical eye). Similarly, Amazon’s reviews are pretty handy.

    I think another factor is trust. I’m tired of adding online accounts with passwords. One good thing with Amazon and eBay is that you can buy from different companies and don’t have to give them your CC info and establish accounts with them.

  7. I think the future will indeed be big marketplace free as more and more innovative services are being released to help independent and free standing retailers.

  8. Comparing an ecommerce platform (Amazon, eBay)with an online ad system (Adsense, AdWords, PPA, etc.) is ludicrious. In this era of outsourcing and specialization, smart companies focus on the activities that add value to their customer base and make operational sense. By taking the DIY route, Borders is going back to the dark-ages.

    This move makes sense ONLY IF Borders can replicate the exceptional user-experience, social (collaborative) elements like customer feedback/ratings, loyalty-building personalization, backend (fulfillment) system, online cross-promotional features and other competencies that Amazon has mastered over the years.

  9. Hi Bubba,

    Yes, feedback isn’t going to be a completely error-free system for rating transaction risk. But it is most certainly much better than having nothing to go on;-)

    As you mention, there’s a great deal of benefit to giving your cc number to only one company for all transactions (PayPal, Amazon)…not having to type (or share) this information with a ton of different merchants provides more overall safety.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.