7 thoughts on “Can eBay Predict Superbowl Champ?”

  1. The Superbowl is an odd example for this data because there is already a direct market for predicting the winner of the superbowl: gambling sites. A site with high volume, and person-to-person instead of a person-against-company, like TradeSports.com, will be a far better predictor.

  2. Of course, no one can argue with those spread makers. i agree gambling sites do tens to be more accurate. still, i though this was an interesting experiment worth sharing with others.

  3. A perfect example of the utter fallacy of economic thinking. Regardless of how people economically value a team what counts is the hundred million unknowable variables that happen on the ground and that are unknowable until the game is played. Things like how are all the players feeling? Will someone trip and have some sort of accident, will the weather favor one team or other, blah, blah. Economists live in models that have little connection with reality.

    As the dot com bubble showed the vaunted “market” is only all too fallible, probably the housing bubble will be the the next example of overinflated markets wrongly predicting the future.

    I welcome comments at raven200 at gmail.com

  4. Matt,

    I agree with you on the fallacy of this thinking. Otherwise, I suppose we all can will the Sun to rise in the west. Or to use Om’s favorite sports, India will win every match, on the thoery that its fan base is more populace.

  5. Aswath,

    my favorite sport happens to be in New York, not in India. and yup, I agree, the population and economic posperity cannot match the “on the ground” reality.

    ebay-mash-up is a different take on the age old trick – calaculating the odds, though i figure in the end that doesn’t make sense.

    if that did, then the Yankees would never lose, but do, more often than the numbers suggest they should. sigh..

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.