31 thoughts on “Social NOTworking”

  1. The market has been going crazy lately. I’ve had several $100 million buyout offers in the last few weeks. not only is my company a single employee company but at 400 million pageviews/month and millions in revenue it is completely unique in todays world. That and its the first major site to be run by an AI

  2. What makes me different is that no other site this size has under 400 employees. (match.com lavalife and yahoo personals)

    What i’ve done is automate the job of hundreds of people, and dropped the technology costs from 1 million/month to ~15k/month. Once all these other social networks/dating sites figure out what i’ve done these sites are going to go from barely profitable to making 10’s of millions a year in profit.

  3. Speaking of social networking, google and nike have come out with a new site for the football community, joga.com. Anybody got a chance to check it out?

  4. Hi Om,

    Thanks for including us in your blog.

    So I have a few comments.

    What we’re really talking about with Jeanette and the rest of our team, is the ability to parlay real skill sets over from one industry to another, in order to fill a very real market need – social networking destinations which are purpose built for a child’s user experience.

    To my knowledge, MySpace or any of the other known open social networking spaces only cater to teenagers on up. Not kids.

    Destinations like our first product, imbee.com, will allow kids to develop their online skill sets “organically” while hopefully minimizing some of the risks associated with the publishing of their personal content. Content that currently finds its way to the entire Internet population – a portion of which as less than best intentions for kids as confirmed in many of the negative press articles related to children and social networking.

    Who better than someone like Jeanette, who besides being an extremely successful technologist is also a mother and that understands what’s missing in many of the social networking spaces where kids end up.

    It really comes down to this….. Jeanette is recognizing the opportunity to fill a market need and has the technical knowledge and resources to deliver a superior product for kids.

    Tim Donovan
    Founder, Vice President of Marketing

  5. “PS: In case you were wondering when there will be a market top – look for a journalist quitting his job to start a social network!”

    Waitaminnit! We can quibble over the semantics of “citizen journalism” vs. “social network” … but isn’t that what Gillmor did? 😉

  6. So Mr. Brookler says they are like Flickr, and you say they are like MySpace… Does that mean you think Flickr is like MySpace? People don’t go to MySpace if they have a lot of photos to share. If Hyperboy is anything like Flickr, I don’t think they’ll need to worry about people wanting to share lots of photos/videos/music going to MySpace to do that, either.

  7. Om Malik wrote:

    PS: In case you were wondering when there will be a market top –
    look for a journalist quitting his job to start a social network!

    Surely, we will see Lou Dobbs quit his job at CNNfn again, to start MyKidsSpace.com (a take on Space.com) at the market top before he returns to CNN with is tail between his legs asking that he have his job back so long as its not “outsourced”!

  8. Om,

    Appreciate for the mention.

    What you may have noticed from the article with John Cook was that ‘his’ first question dealt with competition with MySpace. We are NOT trying to be MySpace, but, right now, when any company mentions anything that has to do with social networking, comparisons to MySpace pop up.

    We are focused on building a community and platform for viewing, managing and sharing all multimedia content types; video, photos, audio and text. We are building a converged experience where users can view, upload and be part of the community from their mobile phones.

    The one part of the article that John Cook didn’t elaborate was the ‘socially focused mission’ that we are integrating into our for-profit business. There is a new emerging trend called Social Entreprenuership and we feel that the focus on the triple bottom line or ‘people, planet, and profits’ will be another differentiator for us. Come back and visit us in our Beta and beyond to learn how we are going to make a difference.

    While I agree there are a lot of social networks coming online, I still believe that there will be a lot of winners. There will only be one MySpace and only one HyperMob and everyone can choose which communities to be a part of.

    Brent Brookler

  9. I’m in total agreement with you Om. Personally, I think building the “flickr of everything” is just as misguided as building “the next MySpace”, but we’ll see. You really don’t need much (if any) funding to push one of these out the door, and frankly the business models are extremely weak.

  10. “I’ve had several $100 million buyout offers in the last few weeks.”

    So, why are you turning them down Markus? The answer to that holds more interest to me than the original article . . .

  11. Social networking for kids? I think this is the goofyest(sp?) idea.

    I have a 5 year old and all he wants to do on the web, indeed all we let him do on the web, is go to pbskids.org.

    I have a hard time thinking about how old a child would have to be to find some interest in social networking. 8 or 9 years old, most likely 10. So given that MySpace is probably capturing kids when they are 12, the useful life of Industrious Kid is mayber 2 years?

    Doesn’t seem to me that one can build a business on that type of runway.

  12. Why sell something for 10 to 20 times profit when you are growing faster then 10% a month? Besides once branded ads come out via adsense, ads rates will double to triple for major sites. Also my site isn’t anywhere near its monitization potential, i barely have any ads. Also the rumor that facebook is valuing its self at 2 billion and looking for funding gives me hope 🙂

  13. While you think social networking for kids is “goofy”..the fact remains that kids want to copy their teenage and / or adult counter parts…and that social networking will most likely be a part of their everyday expirence when they get older.

    Also, since MySpace has an “14 ” age requirement for it’s member population not to mention the fact that there is an enormous amount of adult oriented content being shared – where would you suggest kids go?

    Our feeling is that we don’t foresee social networking disappearing any time soon – and we do see the age bell curve shifting back rapidly – that leaves us with the conclusion that there is a real market need.

    This is confirmed by almost every parent with kids from 8-14 who are looking for destinations – blogging or otherwise – that are more “age appropriate” …we think we’ll be around longer than two years….

  14. Well as the mother of three-8,14, and 17–I can tell you I think there is a REAL need for a site for kids. Yes, 5 is too young but trust me, by the time your child is 8, you’ll be looking for a place for them to go. And it is vital that our kids learn how to navigate and leverage the internet for their futures. The internet will be a huge part of every childs life as they grow and its better for them to figure out some of the do’s and don’ts in a safer envronment. I look forward to seeing what comes out of all these new comers. I want my kids to be able to express themselves and create content, but I want to be sure they can do it without negative ramifications–predators aside, who wants their kids ideas from pre-teen years following them through their lives.

  15. Have you looked at myspace? Parents should be very worried about what their children are either posting or are being exposed to. There are no controls as to what is or is not allowed. Sure they say there’s an age limit but reality is there’s not. For the younger child I think it’s important to provide a safe place for them to enjoy the internet experience. As you wouldn’t let them loose in Time Square to play when they are kids, you shouldn’t let them loose on myspace.

  16. Just because you’re a parent does not make you qualified to start a kids-focused company. It’s admirable, but not really that relevant compared to the experience of an educator or children’s media producer. Plus, you’re already shaking out VP titles? (V P = Doomed.)

    You can’t just create a site for kids. If you’re at all serious, you have to segment by age group, which means at least 2 different sites, with age-appropriate functions and content. You also have to watch it like a hawk with real human moderators. This adds expense.

    Second, kids already have a social network, it’s called school. If their friends aren’t involved; if the content everyone at school is talking about isn’t there — the kids won’t want to be there either. This is a big growth hurdle.

    And revenue? Advertising to kids is a super-sticky business. There’s tons of government/private orgs waiting to pounce on your first misstep. Plus, your audience is going to be too small to really attract the big advertisers for a long time. So, you end up going the subscription route, which kills your growth rate (and any future hopes of attracting advertising).

    My point is really that kids’ internet services are not a new concept (my comments come from my own experience with a children’s internet startup in the 90s). Lots of people have tried and failed. It’s way way harder than it looks.

  17. I agree kids internet services are not a new concept but which ones have any traction amongst kids? The idea of a pbskids or a nick is great but I don’t see them providing what kids want.

    In the 90’s it was as unlikely your 8-10 year old would have a cell phone as it was your teenager would be getting stalked on the internet. Times are changing and we have to face realities. Parents are scared stiff about what is happening on myspace. Maybe these first “kids” sites will fail maybe they won’t but as a concerned parent I feel I have to look for alternatives. Safe alternatives.

  18. What’s puzzling to me is that with all this buzz goign on around social networking, why has http://www.blackplanet.com been totally overlooked? They’ve had millions of members doing the same thing as Myspace since the 90’s. Only, they have effectively mastered the art of the upsell into paid dating subscriptions.

    Oh, and one other thing, Markus, sell now. Don’t say I didn’t warn you. Within the next 12 months the market is going to be flooded with free dating sites that will each take a chunk out of a niche. Those chunks, while good for the sites, are not good for dreams of monopolies or huge marketshare.

    Buzz is your friend, use it while you have it. In about one month it’s gonna be at a fever pitch for http://www.plentyoffish.com but that buzz is also going to give dozens of upstarts publicity as the media wakes up to the free dating market. This in turn will have the companies offering you big stacks ‘o cash now thinking about cheaper options. Those options are plentiful. “Spend 100 million over here on this buzzing site or spend 3 million over here plus 20 million in advertising for this scrappy upstart. Hmm…” It’s a no brainer. Sell now.

  19. anybody who believes that plentyo’fish site has hat 100M buyout offers might be interested in investing in my new startup, i’m creating a social networking site for pet food.

  20. Pierre only the paranoid survive. I have enough money to never work again, and i have the only known algorithms to make this even profitable.

    Unlike social networking, users life expectancy on a site like mine is 3 months, it will not be easy for someone to come in spending $4/member and take it over. Webdate spent 500k a month trying to be a free site before it crashed and burned, and true.com has spent over 70 million the last 2 years and gone nowhere.

    I agree the media is finally starting to clue in, and there is going to be a big battle coming. I am just happy i have 5 times as much traffic as all the other free sites combined.

  21. Very interesting conversation going on here. As part of a new youth focused start up (Uth TV – uthtv.com), I also am amazed at how many players are entering into the social networking game, trying to become the next MySpace. Our aim is a little more modest – tap into the growing segment of youth who don’t necessarily want to go online to flirt but are more interested in sharing their original work, whether that’s a video, song, blog, or photo that they’ve created. There’s no doubt young people want to become ‘popular,’ whether in the school halls or on MySpace. Our bet is that there’s a good portion of them who want something more.

  22. Did you know that over half of the households and forty percent world wide have pets! That’s more households with pets than with kids (excluding goats). If kids can social network ala IMBEE, then theres a far greater market for pets.

    So… after reading this story and the comments, I’ve decided to start http://www.MyPetSpace.com, where pets and their owners can come together and share experiences, pictures, videos and love.

    I think IMBEE is on a trend here, and we’ll follow-up with a number of spin-offs like, MyHouseSpace, MyGardenSpace, MyAuraSpace…etc., as there’s virtually no limit to the potential of the social networking phenomena.

    In order to differentiate ourselves, we’ll build all in Web 3.0, not that Web 2.0 hack job style, but pure Web 3.0 with some of the early Web 4.0 compliant specs.

    This is going to be great.

  23. Ken you might want to check your “trend” facts…According to Pew Research / Yankee Group:

    25 million kids under the age of 13 access the Internet everyday. And more than 50% create their own content. If you had any kids (which I doubt you do) would you want them publishing on the internet for anyone to see? We need more sites like imbee where kids can “graduate online” / where they can begin to learn about communications or collaboration withoutn being put at risk.

    If you want to do pet site that’s your call, but frankly I’m betting that there is a fairly large opportunity in providing “point of entry” sites for kids…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.