45 thoughts on “Indian Telco Offers Free Netbook With a Wireless Contract”

  1. i think that an even more interesting model would be for the network operator to get a fixed cut out of the retail sale of netbooks/laptops and provide lifetime free internet. with the cash flow going business to business they should be able to offer much cheaper prices since they would not have to huge consumer marketing expense.

  2. Free laptops with home Internet connections have been around for a while in the UK and recently this has changed to mobile internet connections and netbooks.
    The problem with providing the internet connection with a laptop is there is rarely any profit on computers, at least not on the low end machines, where as a £20/$40 a month contract ensures a constant revenue stream.

  3. The carphonewarehouse in the UK has been offering free laptops when you purchase wireless broadband for quite a while.

  4. @Arthur Guy

    I agree with you totally. but in rest of the world this is an approach that makes sense and while i think the $30 a month is too much I believe that the free market is going to take care of that. On the netbooks, the profit margins are so low that everyone is looking for volumes – hardware makers to Intel to seller. This can be lucrative for INtel for sure in my opinion.

  5. @Joe_90… I thought that offer was for broadband connections not wireless. Can you clarify and point me to the details of that wireless deal so I can update my post. Thanks

  6. Offers subsidising laptops (to free) have been around of a while in the UK with both fixed and wireless broadband services. Carphone warehouse even offers “free” PS3 or Wii with longer fixed broadband contracts

  7. With a list price in the states of around $300-350 for the Linux-y flavors of Netbooks, and $350-450 for XP versions, you’re basically at the point of the cost of a cell phone (which should kinda beg the question on the BoM for a phone vs a NetBook, but that’s another day’s journey…)

    But make no mistake, computers into developing markets is a long march, not a sprint….

    Going into emerging markets gets you into long-tail/long-headache issues for penetration, specifically power and education. You don’t have to have a high level of literacy to use a cell phone. Power is a more interesting issue that I suspect is going to be overrun by the GreenTech types with a combination of cheap(er) solar and locally generated power (wind, bio, maybe hydro).

    As for Netbooks = cloud computers, I think you’re a little foggy. 🙂 Having sufficient resources to do work when the network is down/unavailable (and it will be down) is the real key to utility, otherwise the X-terminal/Citrix/Failed Larry Ellison company models would have already taken over the earth.

  8. Operators in Eastern Europe have been using the subsidized model for a while now. In fact, Orange Slovakia is apparently the second largest retailer of laptops there! Michael Dell is betting his netbooks will take off based on this model. The surprising element here is that Reliance is not offering WIMAX with this offer, given that they are deploying fixed WIMAX all over India.


  9. @Ram Krishnan

    I think the fact that this is being pushed in INdia where the market is relatively large, this could have a major impact in my opinion.

    I am guessing their decision to not roll out WiMAX just yet is because the networks are not ready while this seems to be ready to go. Of course, there is the issue of what kind of mobility comes with that WiMAX. I wouldn’t write them off just yet.

  10. What I do not understand is how is this offer a wireless broadband offer? We do not have wireless broadband in India so far. The Aircard that Reliance sells is as slow as a dialup connection. To me it makes no sense till we have 3G / Mobile WIMAX.

  11. i just scoured the reliance website for this offer and cant seem to find it. can someone pls give me the link to the offer page or the press release.

  12. I think it is a start of an interesting business model from an Indian company. But the deal is not at all sweet for Indian customers. I have to buy a data plan that will cost me Rs36,000 over a period of 2 years — whose speed is not guaranteed — just because it offers me a netbook that costs Rs16K (Asus Eee). I don’t think it is a good enough incentive.

    But like I mentioned, the business model is new. I hope it extends to smartphones (not the normal phones) whose prices are ridiculously high. A higher end Blackberry model costs nothing less than Rs30K.

  13. Om

    You’ve got to bear in mind that 91% of Reliance’s subscribers use prepaid accounts, not postpaid contract subscriptions. And that $30 is about 2.5x the average India ARPU for the contract customers, and more than 5x prepaid ARPU.


    By comparison, the Dell embedded-3G netbook available on a similar deal in the UK on Vodafone at £25 a month – about 60% of the equivalent average ARPU.

    Interesting though it is, in my view the realistic addressable market for this type of deal is only a tiny fraction of the overall Indian population.


  14. I don’t think this will work well in India. I can’t see typical Indian population (myself being a proud one) moving around with a netbook in their hand. The mobile phone has been so successful mainly due to low cost, availability everywhere and small form factor. I have went to villages with no electricity but with great signal on the cell phone. They pay like Rs. 5 per day to charge the phone with diesel generators.

    Remember bulk of Indians still use a two wheeler as means of transportation. While they can carry a cell phone pretty easily (and perhaps use them while riding a motorcycle), I can’t see them using any device larger than a cell phone.

    Besides, the cell phone is primarily used for text and voice exchange; it’s not being used for web surfing at all. I can’t see folks Googling for a restaurant or a shop on their cell phone, they know that already.

  15. The trouble with any discussion is that there are too many aspects and too little expertise. On top of which, blog comments are usually one off – people comment and get on with life. Why should they stick around?

    The Web is still young. Through trial and error, we would get to know what works and what doesn’t. As a medium, it is so powerful that changes would keep getting swifter and deeper. Then the only worry is how would Big Brother choose to interfere (as it always does in the affairs of men.)

    My take on netbooks is to draw lessons from advertising (??!)

    I have this crazy theory that when the Net is about to destroy a revenue model, it uses an outsider. So Google killed the traditional advertising revenue streams and performance benchmarks.

    There are many such examples. In the same vein, ASUS killed the ultra portable notebook niche. Naturally, it didn’t do so in specs. But in effect. Let’s face it top executives plunk down thousands of dollars on some sleek baby then use it for email (duh!).

    Then we have the roadmap factor. Flash has been with us a long time. We could have had a cheap battery-life-extending HDD-less, ODD-less notebook a long time back, but everything must wait its turn in the great roadmap factor.

    The same roadmap factor has delayed mobile internet options by so many years. A very conspiracy-theory way of putting things would be that the roadmap factor wants to delay mobile internet products and services as much as possible. Then there is the problem of lack of standardization in wireless security. Also why is GPS still out of reach?

    The Internet has caused enough damage to brick and mortar. Having Internet in our pockets would accelerate the process many times over. The only thing that can save brick and mortar is noise. Most people would break down under the information overload. If Big Brother excels at watching, it absolutely shines at confusing.

  16. Though the idea looks quite promising but keeping the current economic meltdown in mind, it may take some time to “really” take off. But with Reliance anything is possible as they are known for their blitzkrieg marketing.

  17. “I like to call them cloud computers.”

    Too much of a mouthful! Lets settle for The Cloudbook. Mmmmmmmmmm.

  18. Pingback: Freeconomics
  19. I was wondering when this was coming. You get a free phone with a 2 year contract with a cel phone company. They now make very cheap laptops designed mainly for browsing the web. Broadband internet packages in many areas of the country are still highly priced (due to lack of competition). Gotta think broadband providers will adopt the loss leader marketing strategy of the cel phone companies sooner or later.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.