20 thoughts on “India Finally Has a 3G Plan; WiMAX in the Mix, Too”

  1. Wouldn’t Google be interested in getting a piece of this? In a country where you can’t swing a dead cat without hitting an incredibly talented engineer – I would think they would want to get Android on par with other Mobile OS’s in a hurry.

  2. Om,

    You are missing some key points when you say that WiMAX is in the mix.

    1. The Govt has admirably cleared the way for deployment of broadband wireless services in the 2.5 GHz band, but they haven’t specified WiMAX which means that any technology can be deployed in either FDD or TDD bands. Basically that is a technology neutral position which actually means that WiMAX is in the mix but so is LTE, UMB and other technologies.

    2. Considering that there are hardly any WiMAX networks with economies of scale, a mobile WiMAX standard that is still under development, no devices etc etc, I find it rather curious that you think 3G will have to compete with WiMAX. It is the other way around…

  3. Andrew

    it seems they are chasing a few handset deals with some carriers in india. Bharti Airtel is said to be close to a deal for Android. Clearly, 3G services in a country like India could be subsidized via advertising and it makes perfect sense for Google to get in there.

  4. Good points Shiv, but there seems to be a lot of movement in the WiMAX world and folks like Intel have been eager funders of WiMAX.

    On your first point, I think DoT order today indicates that they are backing wimax. sure other technologies can play a role.

    if there are links you can send me with more information, i would greatly appreciate.

  5. The spectrum is going to be released in the 2100 MHz band, which would make it compatible with rest of the world, barring a few countries such as the US.

    US, Canada, Brazil, and Australia. Oh, and the parts of Europe that use 900 MHz as well.

    The US did auction off some 2100 MHz spectrum last year. The 2100 MHz band was already being used for other purposes when UMTS was released. Of course, that’s the downlink frequency; the 1900 MHz that most of Europe and Asia use for uplink has been used by PCS 2G services for years.

    Multiband phones are inevitable anyway, just like with GSM.

  6. John,

    Correct me if I am wrong, but it seems like W-CDMA 2100 MHz is probably the most widespread 3G frequency. Is it not the case, or am I missing something?

  7. Oh, and of course Japan is problematic for roaming. If the phone specifically supports the right frequencies for NTT DoCoMo’s FOMA (and is unlocked), then the interface is compatible enough that using a different card will work. KDDI uses CDMA, but on a different frequency than the US/Canada/South Korea.

  8. Om, 3G and WiMax address different needs of the market. 3G is on the Go, while WiMax is for stationary use. WiMax bandwidth for higher speeds (~40 miles/hour) is lower than 3G at the same speed, though I dont have the figures at hand to quote.

  9. Om,

    Here is the link you requested…


    As for the momentum behind WiMAX, you have already written about Sprint’s troubles, the reversal with Clearwire…basically, the point I am making is that all the momentum today is for fixed WiMAX licenses or basically DSL replacement/backhaul and other such applications. This is certainly not competition for fully mobile, commercial and tested 3G that has thousands of devices and rapidly declining ASPs…

    To the other point by John, today 2.1 GHz is the frequency of choice for WCDMA, but you should read up on the momentum behind UMTS at 900 MHz. Elisa in Finland just launched and there is tremendous momentum from Europe in this regard. ATT has also launched at 850 MHz as has Telstra and some Brazilian operators (very new)…3G EV DO services over CDMA2000 networks are widely deployed at 800 MHz.

  10. By bringing in WiMax technology India can become a super power much earlier than expected .Already Telecom revolution has made valuable impact in India’s growth story and this WiMax Technology with speeds of over 55 Mb/s and above will only speed up the economy. .

  11. Yes correct but do you know competition for 3g spectrum humm is like mad. In the bidding side, price is gone like crazy heights truly unexpected expected highs! So I think it wont be cheaper at customer side too. I believe this prob will surly slow down the growth of 3g in country like India!!! Is it?

  12. yeah i too think that the cost would be much higher than the normal calls.And as far as i think that they should try to improve the 2g network first rather than implementing 3g networks.I mean to say that there are still so many places where there is even no network in simple places like at homes in internal rooms.

  13. I just want to say whatever they do plz do it fast…. I live in mumbai & have got google android adp1 so am very eager to test it on 3g network hope the comming network is compitable to my android…. no matter any network my phone is sim unlocked…!!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.