27 thoughts on “Are You Ready for Location-Based Advertising?”

  1. Very interesting article – I remain one of the non-believers but recently at Mobile and Advertising Forum in London when I moderated the event I asked two questions.
    1. Who believes that this is the year of LBS and advertising (40% raised the hand – out of about 100)
    Then I asked,
    2. Will LBS be huge in the next five years – nearly everyone raised their hand.

    In 2002 at the Informa LBS conference in Amsterdam I posed the same question and got the same response.

  2. Om

    Interesting post.

    As one of the early pioneers of location based marketing, I can promise you it’s not the no-brainer it might appear. Back in 2000/1, I was part of the founding management team for ZagMe in the UK, a pioneer in this space. We recruited 85,000 consumers and ran 1500 campaigns for the likes of The Body Shop, Reebok and Burger King. the medium was via sms delivery.

    Lots of lessons were learned and because I realised that we were about 10 years too early, I wrote a White Paper outlining the main learnings – mainly so that the next generation wouldn’t end up making the same mistakes. I’ve made it available for a long time (free) via my blog at http://www.mobhappy.com and would be happy to extend the offer to all your readers too. Just email me at russell AT mobhappy DOT com.

    The main surprise? People always under-estimate the massive amount of advertising you need to sell to ensure that an offer is available at the right time to the right targeted segment. The logistics are truly mind boggling. And the engineering challenge of handing this amount of data on the fly is certainly non-trivial, even today.

    Toodle pip.


  3. Perhaps someone can explain to me what LBA means. I can’t seem to picture a scenario where LBA would work.

    Who is walking around town staring at their phone?
    The phone ringing every time I pass Starbucks or a MickyDs doesn’t sound very nice.

    No. I imagine LBA being more “pLBA” (primary location) where they advertise that a Starbucks is nearby where you live. But they do this already; I get local circulars for Best Buy, Circuit City, heck even Michaels, every Sunday.

    I am not sure what else they can do? Perhaps searching for a store on maps comes with “preferred” stores, or notices of deals? But why do you need a GPS in your phone for that? I have a Palm Centro and Google Maps works fantastically (no ads as of yet), just search “Best Buy 900xx”.

  4. Writing here after a long time…

    Anyways, there’s way too much “Advertisers, advertisers, advertisers.” First of all, no phone can have the viewing window more than around 320px wide by 450px high. The main question is: How can you display advertisement in such a tiny area without messing up a user’s experience? For example, if you’re viewing a map, should ads pop up on the same map? Would you then have enough room to do what you want to do?

    I don’t want anyone to feel like I’m bragging or anything, but my company, hobnobLover is very related to location based service by users and so this article. And, I might be launching a mobile version: hobnobLover.mobile. Again, displaying ads can be very tricky. Like Mr. Malik said, showing “sponsored items” first could definitely push advertising to the next level. (I hope I get a chance to push the mobile version…)

    Anyways, the last few sentences of this article, I completely agree with! 100% true! LBA will definitely be a huge thing, if we don’t mess it up badly, that is!


  5. Hobnob, what are you talking about! Sponsored results being on top are nothing new. In fact I think thats what doomed a lot of the search engines in the early days. I remember every result being plagued by sponsored results – Google does a much better job of this by making it far less obtrusive.

  6. I think you people misunderstood what I was saying. “Sponsored results” as in results that are very related. So, for example, if you were in San Francisco, and wanted to find restaurants nearby, then the ads very related would show up when “searched.” So, I was talking about showing ads when searching from a mobile phone.

    Yuri, I never said there weren’t VGA phones. I was talking about implementing such tech. in phones that people use everyday. Meaning, NOT buying new hardware to support a software.

    FYI, it’s not hobnob, it’s hobnobLover. 🙂

  7. Om:
    Glad to see you back with all the energy. Hope you are done with your cigar. (I know it’s hard).
    Coming back to your Location based marketing, Iam very optimistic and positive about LBS and advertisement. Location based advertisement has great potential, but my concerns are SMS spamming. I guess it should be supported as OPT IN and OPT OUT functionality for users. So in a way, user is given more control on what he is interested, rather than what a product vendor is interested in selling.
    Please check out my article on LBS when u get a chance
    Mobile Killer app is finally here: Part 1
    Mobile Killer app is finally here: Part 1

    @Krishna Chodavarapu
    The phone does not ring when you pass by McDonalds or start buck, it’s just an SMS message with discount details. Now you can argue about who is going to pay for the incoming SMS message. Well, there are ways to cover up those charges.

    I understand mobile form factor is small. But there are ways to convey sufficient information in this small form factor. Also, don’t forget, mobile advertisement is going to be huge and it depends on the same form factor to deliver.

  8. One word —> Privacy

    Explanation. If I am across the street from Dunkin Donuts and I realize that I have been tracked by Ma Bell (or other carrier), I am going to feel really uncomfortable. I might decide at a certain moment to give away my location, but I don’t want it known all the time.

  9. Location based advertising is not meant to track mobile subscriber, the technology is base on cell ID where if the mobile subscriber enter into the predefined zone, it will broadcast the promotional sms. In fact most of the operator will do profilling for merchants so that the customer segment is more targeted.

  10. Our company has many years of specializing in the sale of parrots and accessories, we have gained tremendous experience in this field and have established close relationships with many suppliers.
    We have presented a huge selection of variety and quality of parrots and their accessories at the lowest prices.
    You can order right now and the courier will deliver your order as soon as possible.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.